Homes for Sale in Shelbyville, IL
Shelbyville is the Shelby County seat and the gateway to Lake Shelbyville, one of downstate Illinois' largest and most popular lakes. That combination — courthouse-square downtown, lake economy, and genuine housing variety — makes it one of the most active markets Grissom Schmitz Realty serves. From historic homes near the square to lake-area properties and country acreage, Shelbyville offers options most towns its size can't.
Listed by Grissom-Schmitz RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by The Wallace Real Estate Group, Inc.Listed by The Wallace Real Estate Group, Inc.Listed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by RE/MAX Key AdvantageListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Price AvenueListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Price AvenueListed by Main Place Real EstateListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Lape RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Sphar RealtyListed by Glenda Williamson RealtyLiving in Shelbyville
The housing mix runs from grand older homes near the historic courthouse square to newer construction, lakeside properties, and farms and acreage in every direction.
Students attend Shelbyville CUSD 4, and the town supports a full main-street economy plus lake-season tourism that keeps restaurants and shops busier than the population alone would suggest.
Lake Shelbyville delivers 11,000 acres of water with marinas, campgrounds, and two state parks on its shores; Dam West and the spillway area are minutes from downtown.
Shelbyville real estate FAQs
What is the average home price in Shelbyville, IL?
As of September 14, 2026, there are 41 active listings in Shelbyville, IL with an average list price of $186,859 and a median list price of $159,900. Grissom Schmitz Realty can show you any of them — call 217-562-7078.
What school district serves Shelbyville, IL?
Shelbyville CUSD 4.
Are there homes on or near Lake Shelbyville?
Yes. Lake-area subdivisions, cabins, and properties near the marinas and state parks list regularly, and they're among the most sought-after inventory in the county.
How far is Shelbyville from Decatur and Effingham?
Roughly 40 minutes to Decatur and about 45 minutes to Effingham and I-57/I-70.
What is Shelbyville known for?
Lake Shelbyville recreation, the historic Shelby County courthouse square, and a strong small-town main street.
Nearby towns we serve
Looking for something in Shelbyville?
Tell us what you need and we'll watch the market for you.