Homes for Sale in Findlay, IL
Findlay calls itself the Gateway to Eagle Creek, sitting on the west side of Lake Shelbyville nearest Eagle Creek State Park and the lake's western marinas. For buyers whose priority is getting a boat in the water, Findlay is one of the smartest addresses in Shelby County, and its small-town housing prices leave budget for the lake toys.
Listed by The Wallace Real Estate Group, Inc.Listed by The Wallace Real Estate Group, Inc.Listed by Shelby Realty ServicesListed by Carol & CompanyListed by Shelby Realty ServicesLiving in Findlay
Housing is village single-family homes with rural and lake-area properties in the surrounding township; occasional lake-access listings are the local prize.
Findlay is minutes from Eagle Creek State Park, the golf resort area, and west-side lake access points.
Shelbyville is about 15 minutes south for county-seat services, and Sullivan about 15 minutes east; students attend area consolidated schools, so confirm the attendance boundary for any specific property.
Findlay real estate FAQs
What is the average home price in Findlay, IL?
As of September 14, 2026, there are 5 active listings in Findlay, IL with an average list price of $156,100 and a median list price of $219,000. Grissom Schmitz Realty can show you any of them — call 217-562-7078.
How close is Findlay to Lake Shelbyville?
Minutes. Findlay is the nearest town to Eagle Creek State Park and the lake's west-side marinas.
What recreation is nearby?
Eagle Creek State Park, golf at the resort area, and full lake access for boating, fishing, and camping.
What kinds of properties list in Findlay?
Affordable village homes, rural acreage, and the occasional lake-area property, which tends to move quickly.
Nearby towns we serve
Looking for something in Findlay?
Tell us what you need and we'll watch the market for you.